17th September 2005, 8:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 17th September 2005, 8:53 PM by A Black Falcon.)
Pressure sensitive buttons/dpad? Did Sony really invent the idea? I quite definitely doubt it... and did it really make much of a difference anyway? Seems like it causes as many problems as good effects...
As for the D-Pad, the Gravis Gamepad (or was it the GRiP?) controller showed what it is... a joystick without the stick (that was a gamepad with a center hole thing in the dpad where you could screw in a mini joystick). So maybe Intellivision had it "first", but was that really so different from arcade games with standard eight-way or sixteen-way or whatever joysticks that in effect are just as set (on or off for each direction, not true 2-axis movement)? No, not really. It just gets rid of the stick. :)
The shape was an important advance. So was getting rid of the numpad... what an awful thing to have on a game controller... (Atari never learned this lesson, obviously, when you look at the Jaguar controller...) And as I said, they're all based off arcade sticks anyway... each system was a new step. Of course the NES didn't come out of a void. But it was also quite noticably different from what had come before (controller-wise), and that mattered a lot... the dpad made more sense than the Intellivision disc. :) The NES controller just looks so much cooler than the Intellivision one that it's absolutely no comparison... things like that matter a lot more to most people than things like 'but functionally it's a lot like the Intellivision disc'. :)
Anyway, the Nintendo D-Pad was a big change from what came before, just like how discs or wheels or whatever are big changes from 2600-style "joysticks" that aren't really 2-axis, modern-meaning-of-the-word-joystick things. Intellivision is an atari stick... without the stick. Nintendo Dpad is like that... with a major redesign and directional-focused layout. Change. :)
Similarly, Genesis/Sidewinder/etc circular directional pads with raised parts or whatever to mark the four cardinal directions, as well as PSX-style four-button setups, aren't really true dpads either...
As for the D-Pad, the Gravis Gamepad (or was it the GRiP?) controller showed what it is... a joystick without the stick (that was a gamepad with a center hole thing in the dpad where you could screw in a mini joystick). So maybe Intellivision had it "first", but was that really so different from arcade games with standard eight-way or sixteen-way or whatever joysticks that in effect are just as set (on or off for each direction, not true 2-axis movement)? No, not really. It just gets rid of the stick. :)
Quote:I also dispute that Nintendo created the 'modern' D-pad, because the only thing different about it from the INTV's disc was the shape.
The shape was an important advance. So was getting rid of the numpad... what an awful thing to have on a game controller... (Atari never learned this lesson, obviously, when you look at the Jaguar controller...) And as I said, they're all based off arcade sticks anyway... each system was a new step. Of course the NES didn't come out of a void. But it was also quite noticably different from what had come before (controller-wise), and that mattered a lot... the dpad made more sense than the Intellivision disc. :) The NES controller just looks so much cooler than the Intellivision one that it's absolutely no comparison... things like that matter a lot more to most people than things like 'but functionally it's a lot like the Intellivision disc'. :)
Anyway, the Nintendo D-Pad was a big change from what came before, just like how discs or wheels or whatever are big changes from 2600-style "joysticks" that aren't really 2-axis, modern-meaning-of-the-word-joystick things. Intellivision is an atari stick... without the stick. Nintendo Dpad is like that... with a major redesign and directional-focused layout. Change. :)
Similarly, Genesis/Sidewinder/etc circular directional pads with raised parts or whatever to mark the four cardinal directions, as well as PSX-style four-button setups, aren't really true dpads either...