29th December 2003, 7:22 PM
Did anyone other than LL buy both versions of the films?
As I said, the way you said it was strange... seemed like a long alternate scenario for something you know would not change. But whatever. You are of course allowed to disagree with the director... as for me, I'm not sure. It definitely increased the tension in the film, and in that way it was good, but it definitely did seal Gollum's evil side as having won sooner than in the book.
Quote:What, just because I understand someone's reasons it means I can't disagree? I still disagree regardless of their good and valid reasons!
As I said, the way you said it was strange... seemed like a long alternate scenario for something you know would not change. But whatever. You are of course allowed to disagree with the director... as for me, I'm not sure. It definitely increased the tension in the film, and in that way it was good, but it definitely did seal Gollum's evil side as having won sooner than in the book.