Help Me Choose

[etoven]

I working on the sound track for a new short film...
Below is several variations of the same sequence.
The Scene is melancholy and inspiring:

Everyone vote on the one I should use:

1)
[MUSIC]http://www.tcforums.com/etoven/Music/ENTERPRISE%20Pic.mp3[/MUSIC]

2)
[MUSIC]http://www.tcforums.com/etoven/Music/ENTERPRISE%20Island.mp3[/MUSIC]

3)
[MUSIC]http://www.tcforums.com/etoven/Music/ENTERPRISE%20Panio.mp3[/MUSIC]

4)
[MUSIC]http://www.tcforums.com/etoven/Music/ENTERPRISE%20Mamba.mp3[/MUSIC]

PANIO SPECIAL VERSION)
[MUSIC]http://www.tcforums.com/etoven/Music/ENTERPRISE%20Panio%202.mp3[/MUSIC]

Or.. If you don't like any of them...
Make a suggestion on how I should arrange the piece..

[Great Rumbler]

I'd have to go with #3, but I'm a sucker for piano music.

[Dark Jaguar]

What's up with so many flash media players intentionally dampening the volume? I mean, my PC already has volume control that I've set up myself. If it's too loud, I prefer to use that. Internal flash volume bars that are always at some weird 85% or something is just odd to me. I don't see the point, especially on my laptop where I need all the volume I can push just to make these tinny speakers sing.

As for what song... Hmm... Given the mood you say you're going for, I just can't picture the steel drums working at all, unless it's a somber and uplifting scene during an island luau. The mamba might work if it's Donkey Kong Country but in space... They're nice renditions, but those two just have a more comedic or lighthearted feel to me. I'm going to agree with GR tentatively, in that without knowing exactly what scene it's in, I don't have much to offer. Just knowing the mood, 2 and 4 don't really seem to work. The flute music reminds of Picard playing a flute first in his dream and then in real life, but it also reminds me of graduation day, so I gotta go with GR. Just for the mood, the piano one sounds best to me.

[etoven]

Since the Piano seems to be the running favorite I made a special version with a little cello in the mix.

Admins can change there vote if this is better..

PANIO SPECIAL VERSION
[MUSIC]http://www.tcforums.com/etoven/Music/ENTERPRISE%20Panio%202.mp3[/MUSIC]

[Dark Jaguar]

Nice. Yeah the cello really fleshes it out. That's the best rendition of the theme from Dallas you've done yet!

[etoven]

That's the best rendition of the theme from Dallas you've done yet!

[A Black Falcon]

1 >> 5 > 3 > 4 >> 2

2 is the weakest (and doesn't sound very sad). The other four are close, but I like the first one the best, and yeah, 5 is a little better than 3.