31st August 2011, 6:10 AM
(This post was last modified: 31st August 2011, 6:37 AM by alien space marine.)
Sometimes less is more, I hate to repeat what everyone has already said but the "Noooo" is unnecessary and all it does is remind us of a much parodied final scene of ROTS ruining the impact of this.
You don't need him to say anything to bring across to the viewer that Vader/Anakin is emotionally torn inside watching his son get electrocuted by his boss.
Lucas has the artistic right to change his work but the thing is he didn't make ROTJ by himself other people contributed to it and the last two films were a collaborative effort and only the first film can be considered purely his baby , Richard Marquand directed it & Lawrence Kasdan wrote the screen plays, As far as I am concerned he shouldn't make these kinds of changes no matter how minor without the prior approval & input of the last two film's co-creators.
You don't need him to say anything to bring across to the viewer that Vader/Anakin is emotionally torn inside watching his son get electrocuted by his boss.
Lucas has the artistic right to change his work but the thing is he didn't make ROTJ by himself other people contributed to it and the last two films were a collaborative effort and only the first film can be considered purely his baby , Richard Marquand directed it & Lawrence Kasdan wrote the screen plays, As far as I am concerned he shouldn't make these kinds of changes no matter how minor without the prior approval & input of the last two film's co-creators.