3rd February 2006, 3:29 AM
Now i'm confused. There's alot of weird statements in there.
So the girl is real, her death is real, and Frey felt guilty for it. On a site sent to me by Ryan, it said that the girl commited suicide, but being hit by a train while in a car doesn't sound like that to me, so now there's two different stories that people are talking about. This train girl and that girl commiting suicide. It looks like alot of confusion, the only way to grasp what's happening is by reading the particular passages in question and then looking at what is being run through the mill.
DJ/ His motives are irrelevent? How it affected him is irrelevent? irrelevent to what? ...the book? how can the writer's motives and experiences that caused him to write the book be irrelevent to the book? Again, much confused. Please explain. Obviously if he's lying about about the girl even existing or having a relationship with her then there's cause for alarm, but it still looks like over dramatization to me. I think, from what I see in grumbler's quotes, is that he's saying that he and his girlfriend were playing chicken with a train, crashed, killing her, and causing the train to buckle; leave the tracks, and kill two highschool girls. The investigators say that the high school girls really did die in the train wreck, and they say this Lilly actually died from being hit by a train, apparently. So the facts still seem to be there except now nothing makes sense based on what i've previously heard.
I hear that it was proven he wasn't in any major trouble with the law, but everything else is speculation. The mother of one of the dead girls said "I didnt think he had anything to do with the train accident" OHH PROOF!!! A MOTHER SAID HE MIGHT NOT HAVE HAD ANYTHING TO DO WITH IT! See, that doesn't work.
But either the girl slit her wrists, hung her self, or was hit by a train, or it's talking about seperate people. Waaaay to convoluted. More info is needed.
Has anyone actually quoted the parts of the book with the questionable material online for us to see?
So the girl is real, her death is real, and Frey felt guilty for it. On a site sent to me by Ryan, it said that the girl commited suicide, but being hit by a train while in a car doesn't sound like that to me, so now there's two different stories that people are talking about. This train girl and that girl commiting suicide. It looks like alot of confusion, the only way to grasp what's happening is by reading the particular passages in question and then looking at what is being run through the mill.
DJ/ His motives are irrelevent? How it affected him is irrelevent? irrelevent to what? ...the book? how can the writer's motives and experiences that caused him to write the book be irrelevent to the book? Again, much confused. Please explain. Obviously if he's lying about about the girl even existing or having a relationship with her then there's cause for alarm, but it still looks like over dramatization to me. I think, from what I see in grumbler's quotes, is that he's saying that he and his girlfriend were playing chicken with a train, crashed, killing her, and causing the train to buckle; leave the tracks, and kill two highschool girls. The investigators say that the high school girls really did die in the train wreck, and they say this Lilly actually died from being hit by a train, apparently. So the facts still seem to be there except now nothing makes sense based on what i've previously heard.
I hear that it was proven he wasn't in any major trouble with the law, but everything else is speculation. The mother of one of the dead girls said "I didnt think he had anything to do with the train accident" OHH PROOF!!! A MOTHER SAID HE MIGHT NOT HAVE HAD ANYTHING TO DO WITH IT! See, that doesn't work.
But either the girl slit her wrists, hung her self, or was hit by a train, or it's talking about seperate people. Waaaay to convoluted. More info is needed.
Has anyone actually quoted the parts of the book with the questionable material online for us to see?