Shadow of the Colossus

[Great Rumbler]

Metroid Prime says you are wrong.

Now, I love MP, but it's not the same thing at all. MP relies heavily on adventure elements with much less emphasis on the "running-and-gunning" that you see in almost all standard FPS's. It's the exception to the rule, nothing more.

It would, perhaps, be possible to substitute the d-pad for the left analog stick [movement] and, in that way, have an FPS that only uses one analog stick. However, you're still giving up some amount of control that there's really not need to give up. Virtually every console FPS past the days of the N64 uses the dual-analog control scheme, that is a fact.